Action group rejoicing after winning "David and Goliath" battle

Herefordshire Council's planning committee refused plans for two new superstores in Leominster yesterday.

Herefordshire Council's planning committee refused plans for two new superstores in Leominster yesterday.

First published in News
Last updated

A LEOMINSTER action group opposed to plans for two new superstores in the town is rejoicing after winning its “David and Goliath” battle.

Herefordshire Council’s planning committee yesterday voted against plans for a new food store on land at Southern Avenue and a Sainsbury’s on the current site of steel fabricator Dales on Mill Street.

The decision has been hailed a "victory for the small man" after months of protest by opposition group Friends of Leominster action group.

Pete Blench, a member the group, said: “It’s very much been a David and Goliath battle. We were up against huge forces. The developers and the stores themselves have massive resources – it just goes to prove that if you really exercise democratic right within the system and do legitimate lobbying of the council and do your homework, read all the retail impact assessments and get in the objections then some good can come of that.

“People can be so defeatist when they know they are up against such big and well heeled companies but we still do have a democratic system and a responsive planning system that listens to all opinions – it’s been a victory for the small man.”

But Alex Brodie, director of Morbaine Ltd, the applicant behind the proposed Southern Avenue store, says the developer is “very disappointed” with the decision and that professional advice would be taken before deciding how to move forward.

The store would also fund the relocation of Leominster company Thomas Panels and Profiles to new purpose-built premises in the Enterprise Park.

Mr Brodie said: “We’re very disappointed by the planning committee’s decision. Herefordshire Council officers have themselves stated that our proposal meets a need for new convenience shopping floorspace in Leominster, and there is no evidence that it would have any significant adverse impact on the town centre.

“We are confident there is a market in Leominster for a new convenience store of the size we propose, and we were very pleased with the level of support that we received at the vote from the six councillors who supported our proposal; this was in contrast to the unanimous decision of the planning committee to refuse the Dales site."

And Tricia Thomas, of Thomas Panels and Profiles, said the decision is "incredibly disappointing" and an opportunity missed for both the town and Thomas Panels.

Andrew MacWhirter, managing director of Dales, added that his company will be "reflecting" on the comments, the report and how best to move forward.

Comments (7)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

11:18am Thu 9 Jan 14

Bromyard Boy says...

Small minded and totally unrepresentative of the majority of local residents.
same old story where a minority vocal group pretends that it speaks for the majority.
You do not, I assure you.
Small minded and totally unrepresentative of the majority of local residents. same old story where a minority vocal group pretends that it speaks for the majority. You do not, I assure you. Bromyard Boy
  • Score: -1

11:37am Thu 9 Jan 14

gedina says...

what a disaster for the town.
Money certainly talks, much to the detriment of the true local people, who will now miss out.
what a disaster for the town. Money certainly talks, much to the detriment of the true local people, who will now miss out. gedina
  • Score: 2

1:19pm Thu 9 Jan 14

Herefordboy says...

"there is no evidence that it would have any significant adverse impact on the town centre". Is this idiot for real? Just look in any town/city centre nowadays and try and find an independant greengrocer,fishmong
er,baker etc..Anybody who thinks that is on another planet.
"there is no evidence that it would have any significant adverse impact on the town centre". Is this idiot for real? Just look in any town/city centre nowadays and try and find an independant greengrocer,fishmong er,baker etc..Anybody who thinks that is on another planet. Herefordboy
  • Score: 8

1:34pm Thu 9 Jan 14

redyoll says...

Herefordboy wrote:
"there is no evidence that it would have any significant adverse impact on the town centre". Is this idiot for real? Just look in any town/city centre nowadays and try and find an independant greengrocer,fishmong

er,baker etc..Anybody who thinks that is on another planet.
Well the Planning Committee seem to think there are many greengrocers/bakers/
candlestick makers in Leominster town
[quote][p][bold]Herefordboy[/bold] wrote: "there is no evidence that it would have any significant adverse impact on the town centre". Is this idiot for real? Just look in any town/city centre nowadays and try and find an independant greengrocer,fishmong er,baker etc..Anybody who thinks that is on another planet.[/p][/quote]Well the Planning Committee seem to think there are many greengrocers/bakers/ candlestick makers in Leominster town redyoll
  • Score: -1

2:13pm Thu 9 Jan 14

Bromyard Boy says...

the planning committe were swayed by those with an axe to grind, one that holds no benefits for the real locals.
the planning committe were swayed by those with an axe to grind, one that holds no benefits for the real locals. Bromyard Boy
  • Score: -4

3:12pm Thu 9 Jan 14

basil jones says...

Time the magority spoke up either way !!! My personal feeling is that it is rather sad to stay in the 18th Century !!
Time the magority spoke up either way !!! My personal feeling is that it is rather sad to stay in the 18th Century !! basil jones
  • Score: -1

8:54am Fri 10 Jan 14

B the B says...

Who are the winners here? not the folk of Leominster
Who are the winners here? not the folk of Leominster B the B
  • Score: -2

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree