A Herefordshire town council has yet to resolve the issue of its past meetings having made decisions without a quorate, or minimum, number of councillors present – possibly inviting a legal challenge.
Ledbury Town Council chair Coun Liz Harvey said the issue had only come to light after a consultant from Society of Local Council Clerks (SLCC) “spotted we had misinterpreted the legislation on quorate meetings” during a staff review.
The council had taken the erroneous view that only one-third of its actual number of councillors, currently ten, need be present, rather than one-third of its total theoretical number of 18, i.e. six councillors.
RELATED NEWS :
- Why Ledbury town council meeting decisions could be invalid
- Panic button decision deferred by Ledbury Town Council
- Councillor quits Ledbury Town Council after five months
This put the validity of resolutions passed at 12 meetings between 2023 and last summer into doubt.
“We have been making sure we have six in the room from autumn onwards,” Coun Harvey said. “We just need to deal with history.”
Asked what the significance of this was, Coun Harvey said: “We need to take lawful decisions, whether it’s spending public money, take decisions staff employment, on our own policies, and co-opting councillors.”
What are your thoughts?
You can send a letter to the editor to have your say by clicking here.
Letters should not exceed 250 words and local issues take precedence.
Noting the town’s own internal auditor had not picked up on the issue, she said: “We now have to address it in the best was possible,” and proposed that councillors vote en-bloc to ratify resolutions passed in those meetings.
Coun Ewen Sinclair put a series of questions to the chair and the clerk, including whether such resolutions at inquorate meetings were legal and whether for councillors now agreeing to ratify them would be “breaking the law”.
“Is it wise to push this through without knowing this information, and is the council at risk of a judicial review?” he further asked.
Stay updated with all the latest Herefordshire news that matters to you!
“That’s a lot of questions,” Coun Harvey replied. “Have you provided them to the clerk in advance of the meeting?”
“I haven’t because I only finalised them this afternoon,” Coun Sinclair replied.
Coun Harvey proposed the decision be deferred to the next council meeting “until we have answers to those questions, if councillors feel it’s prudent”.
OTHER NEWS :
- Takeaway’s new ‘gangsta bling’ frontage in historic spot slammed
- Plan for 1,600 new homes could save town's ‘dying’ centre
- More revealed about new multi-storey that will replace Merton Meadow
Backing this, Coun Gary Troy said it was “absolutely essential to do that, where we have a clear conflict of understanding”, and that third-party advice should be sought.
Coun Tony Bradford said the issue “needs to be put to bed as soon as possible”.
Town clerk Angela Price confirmed she had been advised by the SLCC that the council could pass a single resolution ratifying decisions of previous meetings.
Share