Hereford cattle family lawsuit against Government

2
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A dispute over the future of a historic cattle breed has sparked a lawsuit against the Government.

Peter Hall, whose family helped develop Hereford cattle in the late 18th century, is taking legal action against the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA).

He alleges that the Government has failed to protect what he claims are "original" Hereford Cattle from being lost due to crossbreeding.

"This is hastening the eventual disappearance of the original Hereford cattle breed from the British countryside," said Mr Hall, who lives in Australia.

"That is why I am bringing legal proceedings in seeking permission for a Judicial Review into DEFRA’s rules as they are being applied to the Hereford breed.

A man surrounded by cattle.Mr Hall's family invented Hereford Cattle in the 18th century. He now lives in New South Wales. (Image: Woburn Partners)

"I believe they are acting wrongly and – in terms of the survival of the Original Hereford – dangerously in classifying NADs as part of the UK’s Hereford native breed herds."

He alleges that thousands of cattle currently registered as Herefords are in fact North American-derived animals (NADs) with diluted genetics, and not true descendants of the original British breed.

Mr Hall claims DEFRA is failing to follow its own scientific research, which distinguishes between the original Hereford and crossbred NAD cattle.

He argues that including NADs as native Herefords inflates population figures and threatens the survival of the authentic breed.

A spokesperson for DEFRA said: “Native breeds of livestock, like Hereford cattle, are an important part of our rural heritage and we are supporting them, including through grants for grazing under our farming schemes.

“We have followed the latest scientific advice to protect Hereford cattle for generations to come, and ensure there is genetic diversity in the population, a factor that is critical for the long-term survival of the breed.”

The Hereford Cattle Society, the official registration authority for pedigree Herefords, is also named in the legal action.

The society has reportedly refused to register Mr Hall’s Australian-born cattle as purebred Herefords.

They also reject Mr Hall's claim.

"The Hereford Cattle Society is robustly defending its position alongside DEFRA.

"The Society has maintained a closed Hereford Herd Book since 1886 and has continuously adopted advances in science and DNA technology to protect the integrity of the breed," said Seth Wareing, general manager of the Hereford Cattle Society.

Hereford Cattle Society does not accept that the Aberystwyth genetic test Mr Hall presents provides a basis for defining Traditional Herefords as a separate breed.

The hearing, before Deputy High Court Judge Clare Padley, is due to conclude on Thursday with a judgment expected at a later date, according to the Press Association.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos